One of my favorite blogs to read is that of Mark Cuban. He
is a brilliant mind and is unafraid to speak his mind on any subject he so
chooses. I find his commentary on sports to be insightful, his ramblings amusing,
and his posts on business and life to be motivating.
Well, I was browsing through some of his old postings the
other day and came across this one about why he doesn’t wear a suit anymore. I
really enjoyed the post and I feel pretty much the same as he does about suits
and ties at work…they are an outdated nuisance in most instances. There is no need for suits and ties in most
workplaces where a majority of the work being done is either entirely online or
via phone and not face-to-face. The person on the other end of your email or
telephone call wouldn’t know the difference if you had on a suit or were
sitting in your underwear…so why not let employees be comfortable?
However, I think there are some instances where a suit is
needed. Based mainly on tradition and custom, there are many people that expect
certain people doing certain jobs to wear a suit to work. I think that there is
a certain level of respectability and comfort that comes with people in suits and
ties. They look important. They look like they know what they are doing.
Whether or not they are important or really know what they are doing, it is
important in some instances for a person to convey this image.
The three sectors that immediately come to mind where
appearing important and knowledgeable is necessary are politics, law and finance. Would
you trust a lawyer in a pair of sweats to get you out of that speeding ticket?
Would you trust him to explain that mortgage to you? Would you trust your
financial future to a man in shorts and a tee-shirt? Not that politicians are trustworthy, but one without a suit is certainly suspect.
It is important that the people you are serving trust you to
do a job. The near instant image of a lawyer contains a suit and a briefcase.
(Now that I write that I wonder how much of the word ‘briefcase’ comes from
lawyer court briefs…) The image of a successful stock broker contains an
expensive suit, a clean cut, and a nice car. As outdated as these images may
be, they persist and it is necessary to fit within the stereotype in order to
compete in these sectors. People want to hire what they imagine and expect…and in
some sectors that includes a certain dress.
Aside from the conveyance of an image, there is also the
impact on the employee. Again, with the same three sectors I can think of a myriad
of examples. I don’t know if suits really make people work harder, but I think that the argument can be made that dressing
down can lead to a more relaxed view of the tasks at hand. You don’t want your
lawyer lounging in his office when your statute of limitations is about to run.
You don’t want your broker sitting idly by while that stock you wanted to sell
plummets. You don't want your politician to miss that vote that would have brought some 'pork' to your city. So, the argument is there that suits may be a necessary evil…in some circumstances.
That being said, it is the job of management to ensure
things get done as needed. Suits shouldn’t motivate employees…management should
motivate employees. You shouldn’t have to tie a knot on someone’s neck to get
them to work harder…there are so many other ways to do so.
As sad as it is, suits are a necessary evil in many
circumstances and I don’t see them going anywhere. I do think, though, that as
we continue to progress to a more digital, less ‘personal’ society dress
standards will continue to relax. Personally…I cannot wait for that day to
come!
**AFTERTHOUGHT** This morning, as I got ready for work, I went to put on my socks and realized a missed a huge pet peeve of mine when I wrote this. Dress socks suck. I cannot stand the way they feel on my legs and it drives me nuts that all dress socks are made to be pulled at least up to mid calf. I always roll my socks down so that they are just above my ankle...enough so there is all sock when sitting but still low enough that they don't bug me. Someone needs to start making low rise dress socks...I know that I am not the only one with this issue. Just another problem with being required to dress up for work.